Australia’s censorship crusader, Stephen Conroy, compares his proposed internet filtering plan to Google’s censorship policy.
“Notwithstanding their alleged ’do no evil’ policy, they recently created something called Buzz and there was a reaction. People said ’well, look aren’t you publishing private information?’,” Senator Conroy said.
And they promptly addressed the concerns of their customers, something the state doesn’t have to do. If you don’t like the Australian government’s censorship policy, tough. It’s not like there are going to be any alternatives for Australians.
The founder of Google said the following: ’If you have something that you don’t want anyone to know, maybe you shouldn’t be doing it in the first place’.
Admittedly, that is an incredibly stupid thing for a major networking magnate to say. Everyone has things they don’t want other people to know and it’s ludicrous to suggest that they have no business doing those things. What that has to do with Australia’s plan to put the control internet content is beyond me. I suspect it was simply meant to be diversionary.
So when people say ’shouldn’t we just leave it up to the Googles of this world to determine what the filtering policy should be?’ – make no mistake, anybody who wants to go onto Google’s sites now and look up their filtering policy will actually find they filter more material and a broader range of topics than we are proposing to put forward.
But, Mr Conroy, if Google’s customers don’t like their policies, they can go elsewhere. And if that’s a bit difficult to comprehend, just remember, Google got big by luring customers away from other search engines over to Google. Since their customers can go elsewhere, Google has an incentive to provide what customers want. The Australian government has no incentive to please customers because they have a completely captive market.
Communications Minister Stephen Conroy referred to Google’s censorship on behalf of the Chinese and Thai governments when he made his case for Google to impose censorship in Australia.
Nice work, Conroy. You have officially placed Australia in the same club with China. I read recently that China has the most executions of any country. Does Australia eventually plan to follow in China’s footsteps there as well?
